Bad behaviour in the boardroom, and what to do about it

Poor behaviour at the board table can be highly destructive. Here’s how to tackle it appropriately.

At a recent boardroom culture workshop I ran for a group of governance professionals, I was a little dismayed to find how much my remarks on conduct in the boardroom—and what to do about rudeness and incivility—resonated with the audience.

While I don't think there's a sudden epidemic of bad boardroom behaviour, I do think we're not always well equipped to deal with it.

Why it matters

I’m constantly quoting Matt Fullbrook, who tells us that good governance involves creating the conditions for effective decision making. That doesn't happen if people don't feel safe enough to ask a naive question or disagree with the loudest voices. Psychological safety is a precondition for decision quality, not a nice-to-have.

Curiosity, candour, constructive dissent, appreciation, and accountability all raise psychological safety. It's lowered by poor behaviour, which can include judgement, blame, negativity, and authoritarian leadership that shuts the conversation down.

Poor behaviour and rudeness not only interfere with effective decision-making, they're highly unpleasant and stressful for other people in the room.

Why it happens

I've observed that poor behaviour at the board table usually comes from one of three places.

People don't understand their impact. This is the most common. There's a gap between what someone intends and how their tone, demeanour, and phrasing land on the people around them. A director who thinks they're being direct can be experienced by management as derogatory, dismissive, or overly critical. If nobody explains their impact, they have no reason to change.

A misapprehension about what good governance looks like. Some directors still believe that doing the job well means "holding management's feet to the fire" and staying constantly critical. Good governance does involve challenge, but the challenge has to be constructive and in service of the board and organization's goals. Some people feel they need to be snappish, rude, or abrupt to avoid getting too close to management. That isn't independence, and it's not what good governance looks like in 2026.

Some people are simply unpleasant. Fortunately this is the rarest of the three in my experience. These are people who either don't care about their impact or actively want it to be negative.

It helps to know which one you're dealing with. The first two usually respond to feedback, coaching, clear norms, and a better picture of the role. The third needs a firmer route.

Everyone's responsibility

Board culture belongs to everyone in the room. The chair, the CEO, and the governance professional carry an elevated responsibility to prioritize psychological safety, model it, and address behaviour that undermines it. But every director and every member of the leadership team shapes the culture through what they do and what they let slide.

For board chairs

  • Agree norms before you need them. Have a conversation about how the board communicates and handles disagreement. I often teach boards using Kim Scott's Radical Candor model (now also called "compassionate candour")—where you can care personally yet challenge directly.

  • Be clear about expectations and consequences. Put conduct expectations in orientation and policy.

  • Notice good practice. Credit people by name and invite quieter voices in. Small affirmations build safety and trust.

  • Step in early and in proportion. Decide whether the moment calls for a response in the meeting, a conversation afterwards or a formal process, and keep a record.

  • Consider externally facilitated peer evaluations. A strengths-focused peer evaluation, which explores what people want to see more of from their board colleagues, can be a powerful tool for improving the way everyone shows up at the table.

Know where coaching ends. Feedback and norms work for people who didn't realize their impact or who misread the role. When someone understands how they're landing and carries on anyway, it's no longer a coaching conversation. That's when you need to move to a formal route, such as your code of conduct or your governance committee, supported by your factual record. And follow through: the rest of the board, and the leadership team, are watching what happens, and whether the bad behaviour is being addressed.

For everyone else in the room

You don't need to be the chair to act. I like the following five Ds of boardroom intervention (adapted from Right To Be) because they give you options short of confrontation:

  • Direct: name it or reframe, calmly and briefly. "Let's come back to the issue in front of us."

  • Distract: interrupt without confronting. Ask a new question or suggest a break.

  • Delegate: bring in the chair or vice-chair.

  • Delay: check in afterwards. "I don't think you meant it, but it may have landed as..."

  • Document: keep a note of what happened.

The aim is calling in rather than calling out: letting someone know a comment landed badly, usually in private, and allowing them room to learn. And when you're the one who got it wrong, pause, listen, acknowledge and try again.

For governance professionals

Your authority may sometimes be limited, but your influence is not. You work closely with the chair and leadership, see patterns across meetings and committees, and hold responsibility for governance processes, including board and director evaluations, agendas, norms, and by-laws.

  • Before: brief the chair on likely tensions, and build conduct expectations into onboarding.

  • During: support the chair, including by suggesting a short break when the temperature rises.

  • After: follow up with the people involved, reinforce conduct expectations, and feed your insights and observations into board evaluations.

A couple of questions to consider

When did your board last talk about its culture and communications norms? And if someone behaved badly in your next board meeting, who would say something?

If you'd like to talk about norms, chair support, or how to build all this into your board's practice, I'd love to hear from you.

Next
Next

Governance and wellbeing: the results are in